Capitulation

Well, the man of steel has capitulated and decided to accept Labor’s proposed amendments to the FTA enabling legislation, in order to tie up the FTA before parliament takes a break for a couple of weeks.

Sedgewick has described it quite aptly as a non-core back flip in the comments section of this thread over at Back Pages. This is because of the man of steel’s attempt to dress up any problems as “all labor’s fault”.

In fact, a quick survey of the transcript, the PM has this to say:


[the amendments] could however have adverse affects on Australian companies and that has been pointed out to the Labor Party

it will be on the Labor Party’s head and nobody else’s head if a difficulty in finally implementing the agreement arises

I have communicated these concerns to the Labor Party

it would be entirely the fault of the Labor Party and nobody else’s

if in the final analysis the insertion of the amendments presents a problem well that will be the exclusive fault of the Labor Party, not my fault

if in the final analysis the acceptance of these amendments does cause a problem it will be the fault of the Labor Party and nobody else

if it does cause a problem then the Labor Party will be to blame and nobody else

I therefore want it to be fully understood by everybody that if a problem does arise it will be exclusively the fault of the Labor Party

the undermining has been done by the Labor Party

So if there is a problem, it will be exclusively the fault of the Labor Party

These are all separate statements in one press conference. D’you think he had a particular point he wanted to communicate? A particular soundbite he would be happy to get out?

One Response to “Capitulation”

  1. 1
    Carl Says:

    Yet again the man of steel refuses to take responsibility for anything.

    Now I’m no parlimentary expert, but I would expect that my elected leaders take some responsibility in analysing, debating and then voting on ammendments and bills.

    It’s just not good enough to say, “Yeah we’ll let this one through, BUT …” If Howard thinks there’s a problem with the ammendments, then the Liberal government simply shouldn’t let them through.

    It feels obvious to me that Howard wants it passed and swept under the carpet quickly. He’ll praise it during the campaign and Labour can’t say anything bad about it because they would’ve passed it in the Senate.

    Just stupendous me thinks.

    C.