Prosperity Theology vs Poverty Theology II

We have been discussing the merits (or lack thereof) of competing ideologies that Mark Driscoll has labelled “Half Truths”.

I came across this comparison that I thought makes some sense by comparing the two theologies with a ’stewardship’ theology.

Theological Perspectives on Money

By Patrick M. Morley

Many Christians suffer for lack of a theology of money. They don’t have a way of integrating their financial practices with their Christian commitments. But it is not enough just to have a theology of money; it is critical to have the right theology of money. In our day, there are a variety of theologies of money on offer, some better than others. These can be boiled down to three basic options: (1) poverty theology, (2) stewardship theology, and (3) prosperity theology. These three theologies are summarized in the table below. Each of the three theologies attempts to summarize the relevant biblical material, but in our opinion only one does so in a satisfactory way. Look over the table below, study what the Bible has to say, and decide for yourself whether stewardship theology is not the best representation of the biblical perspective.

Poverty
Theology
Stewardship
Theology
Prosperity
Theology
View of
Prosperity
Nonmaterialistic, disdain for possessions Possessions are a trust given in varying proportions Prosperity is the reward of the righteous
In a Word, Possessions Are a curse a privilege a right
Scriptural Reference Luke 18:18-22
sell, give to poor
(rich young ruler)
Matthew 25:14-30
parable of talents
Matthew 7:7-8
ask, seek, knock
Mitigation Proverbs 21:20: In house of wise are stores of choice food & oil, but a foolish man devours all he has None Proverbs 23:4-5: Don’t wear yourself out to get rich
Needs Met By “carefree attitude”
don’t worry—seek kingdom first
Matthew 6:25-34
“faithful administration”
1 Corinthians 4:2; Matthew 25:21, 23
“transaction” tithe for a blessing
Malachi 3:10
Concept Rejecter Steward Owner
Attitude
Toward Poor
We are We care We owe
Preoccupation Daily needs Wisdom Money
Attitude Carefree
(Proverbs 3:5-6)
Faithful
(Luke 16:10-11)
Driven
(Proverbs 10:17)

Source

61 Responses to “Prosperity Theology vs Poverty Theology II”

Pages: « 1 2 [3]

  1. 61
    Greg the explorer Says:

    yes…my secret is out

Pages: « 1 2 [3]